Understanding Your Options for Replacing Missing Teeth: Which Solution Is Right for You?

When you lose a tooth, it’s not just a cosmetic issue—it can affect your overall oral health and daily quality of life. Whether due to aging, injury, or decay, tooth loss is a common issue many people face. So, what are the best ways to replace a missing tooth? Let’s explore the three primary options: removable prostheses, dental bridges, and dental implants.

1. Removable Prostheses: The “Show Tooth” Option

Removable dental prostheses devices are pieces that are easily moved in and out of your mouth; in other words, they are not permanent, fixed solutions.

‍

Types of Removable Prostheses

When it comes to replacing missing teeth, this category has a few different options available to you:

A retainer with a fake tooth, also called an Essix retainer, serves as a temporary solution with a fast turnaround time – usually a day, and sometimes even a matter of hours – and it is geared toward patients who have only one missing tooth. With an Essix retainer, you have to remove the retainer every time you eat, and then brush your teeth before putting the retainer back in your mouth.

‍

A Dental flipper, also called an interim partial denture, flipper tooth, or flipper denture is slightly more durable than an Essix retainer and takes about a week or two to have in hand. Similar to an Essix retainer, it is intended to replace a single missing tooth. The difference is that you can leave it in your mouth while you eat, but you need to avoid chewing the food with the flipper’s fake tooth.

‍

A removable partial denture is slightly more durable than a dental flipper, since it contains metal and is a little bulkier. This option is geared toward patients who are replacing multiple missing teeth, and the turnaround time is typically several weeks, since a dental lab has to make it. A removable partial denture typically negatively impacts the neighboring teeth, since it is anchored on them, and the process may even involve getting crowns on those teeth. Patients find that this choice is not aesthetically pleasing, because the metal hooks are visible in their smile.

‍

Advantages of a Removable Prostheses:

• Affordability: If you’re limited by cost, removable prostheses are cost effective. However, you may need to replace them repeatedly over the long run, so the lack of durability and longevity should be factored into your decision.
• Quick Turnaround: Removable dental prostheses are made fairly quickly, in a timeframe that ranges from hours to a couple of weeks – a few weeks if you’re getting a removable partial denture.

‍

Drawbacks of a Removable Prostheses:

• Functionality: These appliances are primarily for looks and lack chewing strength.  Food can easily get stuck underneath, and they can be a nuisance when it comes to day-to-day care and maintenance.
• Embarrassment Factor: You may need to remove them when eating, which can be awkward in social situations.
• Aesthetics: While they look fine from afar, up close, the plastic or metal components often make it obvious that they aren’t natural teeth.
• Lack of Durability: Being that they are not long-term solutions, you will need to plan to replace them repeatedly.

‍

While all of these types of removable dental prostheses are more affordable solutions to replace missing teeth, with faster turnaround times, they are severely lacking in functionality and are not considered long-term solutions. Retainers, flippers and dentures are like “show teeth” – they look decent from a distance but aren’t designed for chewing. If you’re looking for a quick, temporary fix and don’t mind the limitations, this option might suit your needs. However, most patients find this solution cumbersome and  inconvenient for long-term use.

At Alpers Family and Cosmetic Dentistry, we typically only use removable prostheses as a short-term solution during the process of getting a bridge or an implant. For example, an Essix retainer is a great temporary solution for a patient who has a post inserted and is waiting to receive their final crown for their dental implant. We hardly ever recommend choosing this option as a final solution to replace missing teeth.

Comparison of Tooth Replacement Options

‍

2. Dental Bridges: A Reliable But Invasive Option

A dental bridge has historically been a go-to solution for replacing missing teeth. It involves placing dental crowns on the teeth adjacent to the gap, with a fake tooth filling in the space. This option mimics the look and function of natural teeth, but it comes with some caveats.

Advantages of a Dental Bridge:

• Natural Feel: A well-made bridge can look and function quite like real teeth.
• Faster Turnaround: A bridge can often be completed in a few weeks, making it a quicker solution than an implant.

‍

Drawbacks of a Dental Bridge:

• Involvement of Neighboring Teeth: To place a dental bridge, the healthy teeth on either side of the gap must be filed down to fit crowns. This is a major drawback, especially if those neighboring teeth don’t require treatment. Not only does this mean treating teeth that don’t need dental work, but it also accelerates the need for future treatment on those teeth. Over time, choosing a dental bridge could lead to more tooth loss, as the treated teeth become compromised.
• Longevity Issues: A dental bridge will likely not last beyond 10 years. Most of the time its lifespan is even shorter than that.
• Cleaning Difficulties: If you have a dental bridge, you typically have to put more effort into your oral care routine when it comes to cleaning, brushing and flossing them. Food often gets stuck under the fake tooth and in between the others, potentially leading to decay or damage to the adjacent teeth.

‍

As you weigh the advantages and disadvantages of getting a dental bridge, you should also factor in your age. For senior patients, a bridge might make sense, depending on how old you are and what your goals are. In contrast, Dr. Alpers rarely recommends a dental bridge on a younger patient. The other point to consider is the health of your neighboring teeth. If the teeth on either side of the missing tooth are already damaged or need crowns, a bridge might make sense for you. But if those teeth are healthy, it’s better to explore other options–namely, a dental implant.

‍

3. Dental Implants: The Best-In-Class Option For Tooth Replacement

For a long-lasting, natural-looking solution, dental implants reign supreme. Implants consist of a titanium post that’s surgically placed in the jawbone, acting as a tooth root. After healing, a crown is attached, offering both function and aesthetics close to a natural tooth. At our Scottsdale dental office, we believe that a dental implant is almost always the best choice when replacing teeth and most closely replicates natural teeth.

Advantages of Dental Implants:

• Conservative Approach: Unlike a bridge or removable denture, an implant doesn’t affect the surrounding teeth.
• Ease of Procedure: Most patients are surprised to hear that the dental implant procedure is one of the most predictable procedures in dentistry. It’s a fairly quick procedure, and most patients find that they have minimal discomfort during the healing process.
• Longevity: With proper care, an implant can last 20–30 years or even longer, making it a more durable solution.
• Natural Functionality: Implants look, feel, and function almost exactly like natural teeth, providing confidence when eating and smiling.

‍

Drawbacks of Dental Implants:

• Longer Turnaround Time: A dental implant takes longer to complete than a bridge, due to the healing period after the post is placed. However, it’s important to note that the additional waiting period with an implant helps ensure a longer-lasting and more successful outcome. Most patients find it’s worth the wait!

‍

A dental implant is the best choice for a long-lasting solution that most closely mimics a natural tooth. If you're looking for dental implants in Scottsdale, you've come to the right place! At Alpers Family and Cosmetic Dentistry, we offer cutting-edge Scottsdale dental implant dentistry to restore your smile's beauty and function.

‍

‍

Discover Your Smile Solution: Why a Personalized Consultation is Key

The best way to determine which tooth replacement option is right for you is to schedule a consultation with your dentist. Dr. Alpers firmly believes in tailoring each treatment to fit the unique needs of every patient, as no two cases are exactly the same. The right solution depends on several factors, including the health of your remaining teeth, the condition of your gums, and your long-term oral health goals. In some instances, Dr. Alpers may recommend a combination of treatments to ensure a more conservative approach, prioritizing what’s in your best interest to achieve the best results while preserving as much of your natural smile as possible.

‍

‍

“What I enjoy most about placing dental implants is seeing how transformative they can be for my patients. If it’s a dental implant for a back tooth, it’s the difference in making someone’s mouth whole again. If it’s a front tooth, it’s a complete game-changer for them both physically and emotionally. And as a dentist, the entire process is quick, predictable and seamless.” - Dr. Kris Alpers, Alpers Family and Cosmetic Dentistry

‍

Weighing the Costs: What’s the Best Value for Replacing Missing Teeth?

Many people are surprised to learn that the initial cost of a dental implant and a bridge is often very similar. While implants may seem more expensive, they offer greater longevity and fewer maintenance costs over time. A bridge, which might need to be replaced after 10 years, maybe 15 years if you're lucky, can end up costing more in the long run due to potential damage to surrounding teeth.

Cost of Dental Bridge vs. Dental Implant

‍

Comparison between the two options in a typical scenario

As this chart above indicates, a dental implant will likely cost you less than a dental bridge over the long run. And although removable prostheses is the most cost effective option in terms of initial cost, you may need to replace it repeatedly over the long run, like you would a dental bridge. All in all, durability and longevity should be factored into your decision.

Think the Dental Implant Procedure is Painful? Here's The Real Story

One of the biggest misconceptions about dental implants is that the procedure is long and painful. However, for highly trained professionals, implant placement is one of the most predictable procedures in dentistry. Most patients report minimal postoperative discomfort, and are pleasantly surprised by how quick the final procedure is and how seamless the entire process is.

Conclusion: Dental Implants are the Best Option for Long-Term Success

When weighing your options, it’s clear that dental implants are the most durable, natural-looking, and functional solution for replacing missing teeth. While retainers and bridges offer viable alternatives, they come with limitations in terms of aesthetics, functionality, and long-term value.

If you’re considering replacing a missing tooth, take the time to consult with your dentist about the benefits of dental implants. They may take longer to complete, but their lasting benefits far outweigh the wait. In the end, a dental implant is not just a replacement—it’s a restoration of your smile, confidence, and oral health.

Dr. Kristopher Alpers is highly skilled with advanced training in dental implants. In fact, he serves as a mentor for The Implant Pathway program, where he coaches and helps train other dentists in advanced techniques with dental implants.

Want to learn more? Call us at 480-998-3355 today to schedule a consultation and see what the best tooth replacement option is for you!

‍